FMA vs FMA:B
2 posters
Page 1 of 1
FMA vs FMA:B
so in case anyone has watched both Fullmetal Alchemist and Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood i what a healthy debate which do you think is better both overall and in detail and why,
for me personally Brotherhood takes the win its more coherent follows a better narrative closer to the Manga and the ending is far superior and doesn't ruin the whole thing by giving Ed some god mode alchemy deus ex machina bull crap.
debate have fun and apologies for the thread if i'm on my own with seeing them both (hopefully not)
for me personally Brotherhood takes the win its more coherent follows a better narrative closer to the Manga and the ending is far superior and doesn't ruin the whole thing by giving Ed some god mode alchemy deus ex machina bull crap.
debate have fun and apologies for the thread if i'm on my own with seeing them both (hopefully not)
Arnier the fallen- Filthy Grey Skin
- Posts : 181
Join date : 2013-03-25
Age : 34
Location : Wales uk
Re: FMA vs FMA:B
Up until the death of Hughes, I'd go with the original. After Hughes' funeral, Brotherhood. That was the biggest (and only, really) disappointment for me with Brotherhood - the fact that Hughes' death just did not have as much emotional weight as it did in the original.
Re: FMA vs FMA:B
Grimnir wrote:Up until the death of Hughes, I'd go with the original. After Hughes' funeral, Brotherhood. That was the biggest (and only, really) disappointment for me with Brotherhood - the fact that Hughes' death just did not have as much emotional weight as it did in the original.
yeah i get what you mean they only really touched in it for one episode in brotherhood, but kinda made up for it with the better ending IMO although sying tht i would have liked hughes's death to have a more lasting impact with who they got involved and how they dealt with things, if that makes sense
Arnier the fallen- Filthy Grey Skin
- Posts : 181
Join date : 2013-03-25
Age : 34
Location : Wales uk
Page 1 of 1
Permissions in this forum:
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
|
|